Christy Love really wants a baby, but she's having trouble conceiving with her husband. When she realizes that her stepson, Jay Romero, looks just like his dad, she gets the idea that she can get Jay to knock her up and no one will ever know the difference. She proposes the idea to Jay and he tentatively agrees, which finds them chatting baby names at the table. Thinking about names makes it all too real and Jay tells Christy he's backing out of the deal.