When Jay Crew heads back to his date's house for what he thinks will be a satisfying fuck, he never could have predicted who he'd actually end up fucking. Turns out that his date's new stepmom, Syren De Mer, is far more interested in a big cock than knitting, and she's also taken horny college student Sia Lust under her wing. When Jay nearly gets caught messing around on a "tour" of the house, he walks in on Sia and Syren pillow-humping and scissoring. From there, Jay happily joins an unexpected threesome, narrowly avoiding getting caught yet again. After draining Jay's cock of all its cum, Sia and Syren manage to sneak away, leaving Jay and Sia's sister to take the blame for cheating.